Most Popular Ice Cream

[moksha]

According to Ranker, the top ten most popular ice creams are:

1. Cookies and Cream
2. Vanilla
3. Chocolate Chip
4. Chocolate
5. Strawberry
6. Vanilla Bean
7. French Vanilla
8. Moose Tracks
9. Rocky Road
10. Coffee

This list seems rather loaded toward vanilla. It does not match my own list.
What would you put on your list?

[Reuben]

Chocolate with cookie dough.

Ben & Jerry's has a low-fat version that's kind of amazing.

I think most desserts that don't contain chocolate are pointless.

[RubinHighlander]

Over the years we've found settled on the Tillamook brand as our favorite. I'm good with their old fashioned vanilla, dressed up with bananas, Ovaltine chocolate malt, rice crispies, and hot fudge. Fully enjoying this mix requires proper preparation. You'll need to get some THC herbal supplement in your system, get your best headphones, dial up your favorite music (I find Billie Ellish or Cold Play pairs well), then go out and watch a sunset or in the moonlight. A bonus is a hot tub soak while you consume this magic. Every bite is truly a transcendent experience! Trust me on this one!

[Apologeticsislying]

That list looks A-OK with me! Probably not in that order, but a fantastic list all the same.

[wtfluff]

I don't recall ever meeting an ice cream that I didn't like.

Or a penguin for that matter.

[moksha]

1. Chocolate with Brownie Bits (goes by a variety of names)
2. Coffee
3. Dulce de Leche
4. Rocky Road
5. Mango Sorbet
6. Orange Creme
7. Raspberry Ripple
8. Fudge Ripple
9. Mint Chocolate Chip
10. Cherry Garcia

Hey does anyone out there like that Japanese green tea flavor ice cream?

[Fifi de la Vergne]

What would you put on your list?

Ben & Jerry's Chubby Hubby!

[2bizE]

Chocolate
Chocolate
Chocolate
Chocolate
Huckleberry
Pralines and Carmel
Strawberry revel

[Hagoth]

Also, Mrs. Hagoth and I were at a little raman bar in Manhattan last year and they had two flavors of soft serve: popcorn and dill pickle. Both were startlingly delicious!

[Random]

According to Ranker, the top ten most popular ice creams are:

1. Cookies and Cream
2. Vanilla
3. Chocolate Chip
4. Chocolate
5. Strawberry
6. Vanilla Bean
7. French Vanilla
8. Moose Tracks
9. Rocky Road
10. Coffee

This list seems rather loaded toward vanilla. It does not match my own list.
What would you put on your list?

Peppermint ice cream way at the top (without those nasty little chocolate pieces ruining everything)
Black licorice right next to it
Banana (okay, I've only seen them in bars on a stick, but they are delicious)
Caramel ripple
Butterscotch ripple
Raspberry (I think I've only seen this in ripple kinds)

That's probably it. There are other flavors that are okay, but those are my top ones.

[MerrieMiss]

Peppermint ice cream way at the top (without those nasty little chocolate pieces ruining everything)
Black licorice right next to it

Absolutely! I usually choose chocolate because it's always available, but peppermint, pistachio, and black licorice are the best! Tillamook used to do a white licorice years and years ago on location, which was both delicious and didn't leave your mouth black/green. I wish they'd bring it back.

[Random]

Tillamook used to do a white licorice years and years ago on location, which was both delicious and didn't leave your mouth black/green. I wish they'd bring it back.

I would definitely try that if it came around.

[deacon blues]

Pralines and Cream
Carmel Cashew
Toffee (Heath bar)
Strawberry
Blueberry
Chocolate Almond
Raspberry
Moose Tracks
Strawberry Cheesecake
Butterscotch Pecan

[Lithium Sunset]

Goodness... ten is too many for me. I guess my scope has narrowed since being GF...Good bye cheesecake ice cream.

My favorite would be Vanilla and Caramel.